Categories
BLG Leadership Insights Features Managerial Competence

When Stars Align: Thibodeau’s Bulls

Motivating some star employees to peak performance can often seem a fait accompli – akin to pressing the Staples EASY button. No matter the situation they always seem to come up roses. Many leaders are smug enough to believe that this is directly correlated with their leadership, and in a great number of cases it might be. The best leaders, however, understand that peak performance is what stars produce, and it’s not always a function of their leadership. The real question they should be grappling with is does my star elevate the entire team?

In sports, this is a foundational principle. All great coaches understand that getting peak performances from their stars is just the beginning, because the team’s success is the culmination of interlocking individual successes. They also understand that for the team to achieve it’s peak, the star must invest themselves in making the team better. For both the star and the coach it’s a delicate balancing act requiring them to be simultaneously of, and above, the team.

Imagine a leader who inherits an underachieving staff of primarily twenty-somethings, from three continents, 73% of whom have less than a year of tenure with the company. How do you raise that team to the top of their industry? Chicago Bulls Coach Tom Thibodeau knows how. He took such a motley crew; tied the NBA record for most wins by a first-year coach (62 wins out of 82 games); positioned the team for a championship run; and was recently named NBA Coach of the Year.

What gives?

It happened primarily because the coach and his star player are in total alignment. When you listen to star point guard Derrick Rose, a third-year player who, incidentally, was recently voted the NBA’s MVP it comes into clear focus. Like a coach he’s quick to deflect individual credit; he highlights his mistakes rather than his achievements; and he’s equally satisfied scoring or setting up others to score. In short, his vision for success is his leader’s vision for success.

The 22-year old Rose, understands that the team is better when he selflessly uses his ability to put his teammates in positions where they can be successful. Both coach and star realize that to be a championship contender, the team has to be greater than the sum of its parts. This makes Rose a pretty rare star indeed – in the mold of MVP-caliber athletes like Tom Brady, Magic Johnson and Derrick Jeter.

How do you get there?

First, coach and player lead by example. Thibodeau is the team’s hardest worker, followed closely by Rose. Second, the sacrifices they make for the good of the team are readily apparent and command loyalty and respect. Third, Thibodeau coaches every individual on the team, especially his star, extremely hard. Thus, rather than merely raising the ceiling for his star, he raises the floor for everyone else.

As a result Rose can trust that his teammates, who have accepted and responded to his leadership, are prepared to make meaningful contributions when called upon. In other words, they’re all in it together. This eliminates the probability that the star only positions himself above the team as former Bulls star, Michael Jordan, did when he famously referred to his teammates as “my supporting cast.”

When leaders and star performers are “all in” for the big win, it encourages everyone else on the team to sublimate themselves to achieve collective success. For the Chicago Bulls, it means that everyone is not only on the same page, they are on the same word of the same page. Both coach and star have locked arms and infused everyone else with their will to win. How many leaders can say that?

Picture Credit: Charles Van L.

Categories
BLG Leadership Insights

Don’t Recruit Like the NFL

In the NFL’s annual draft the worst teams select rookie players earlier. This is done so losing teams will get the best players and keep the NFL balanced and competitive. Subsequently top draft picks are highly coveted by teams. Quickly glancing at the draft orders of the past decade reveals this line of thought to be flawed. As it turns out the same teams are continually at the bottom of the league and at the top of the draft. New research by Professor’s Cade Massey and Richard H. Thaler posits that the highly valued first pick in the draft is, on average, the least valuable pick in the first round.

In The Loser’s Curse: Overconfidence vs. Market Efficiency in the National Football League, Massey and Thaler compare the market value of draft picks with the actual performance of the players selected. They found that NFL teams overvalue the highest picks in the draft. Their analysis shows that players chosen early rarely perform well enough to justify the trade value of their pick and that players selected later in the first and second rounds offer the best value. Thaler and Massey note that psychological factors such as overconfidence, false consensus, and ‘the winner’s curse’ distort NFL teams’ ability to accurately predict the future value of the players they draft.

So how does the selection of world-class athletes relate to the world of leadership and organizational structures?

Massey and Thaler’s findings about the market for football players extend to any labor market where organizations select talent. Meaning their observations can help shed light on selecting new CEOs to newly minted graduates. In the world of business, too often we try to hit home runs: confident that one big hire or staff expansion will spur a team towards prolonged success. In doing so, we forsake consistency and reliability in the hope that a savior is on the way. As Bob Nardelli and Howard Stringer can attest merely being called a savior and actually being one are two very different things.

As Thaler and Massey write: “In our judgment, there is little reason to think that the market for CEOs is more efficient than the market for football players. Perhaps innovative boards of directors should start looking for the next Tom Brady (pick number 199 of 210) as CEOs rather than this year’s hot young prospect.”